Looks like two different bucks to me as well. If in fact it is two different bucks, they are definately from the same gene pool.

I think from this you can clearly see they are different deer.

Buck...

I'm not aguing with you.....and I did that side by side comparison, too. If you tilt the one on the right up a little....they are the same "angle". Note the curve inward of the left main beam on both photos.

Like I said.... back on page 3....

what kinda camera are you using?

It's a moultrie 2.0 (3.1 megapixels).

Ok after looking for two days here is the gospel

They are not the same deer. You have at least 2 nice ones.

The browtines are different, one on the left straight, one on the right both tilt inward.

What do you think EACH would score, gary?

I would say the are both +90 to 110deer(if the other side catches up).

The one with even rack here is my guess, buckeye is way better than me at guessing.

Both out side the ears 15''
MBR 17'' MBL 17''
G1R 3.5'' G1L3.5''
G2R 5'' G2L 5''
G3R 4'' G3L 4''

H1R 3' H1LR 3'
H2R 2.5'' H2L 2.5''
H3R 2''H3L 2''
H4R 1.5''H4L 1.5''

Mornin

I am not arguing either [8D]Just posting my opinion.... To me it looks like good news to you that you have a couple older age class bucks on your property.