55# Takes Yukon Moose!!!
#131
Guest
Posts: n/a
ORIGINAL: davepjr71
So, you are only a real hunter if you use a longbow? Now that's BS. And again seems to show the superiority complex that some guys have. A guy starts shooting traditionaland then automatically he's doing the only real hunting. Cracks me up every time.
So, you are only a real hunter if you use a longbow? Now that's BS. And again seems to show the superiority complex that some guys have. A guy starts shooting traditionaland then automatically he's doing the only real hunting. Cracks me up every time.
#132
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 2,188
Likes: 0
From: Balt, MD (orig: J-town,PA) The bowels of Hell!!!
Me too stupud for all of you guyz on hear.
You said people have lost the real meaning of hunting. What exactly do you mean by that? To me it reads that if you use a high poundage bow you've lost the meaning of hunting. that has nothing to do with the meaning of hunting. it's a person's preferences in weapons.
And comparing a high poundage bow to 300 mag is rediculous. The bows are lower poundage than they used to be. I could see making a comment if everyone were using 120# compounds. You guys rip on quick for making that comparison and yet use it yourself for your own means.
You said people have lost the real meaning of hunting. What exactly do you mean by that? To me it reads that if you use a high poundage bow you've lost the meaning of hunting. that has nothing to do with the meaning of hunting. it's a person's preferences in weapons.
And comparing a high poundage bow to 300 mag is rediculous. The bows are lower poundage than they used to be. I could see making a comment if everyone were using 120# compounds. You guys rip on quick for making that comparison and yet use it yourself for your own means.
#133
Guest
Posts: n/a
ORIGINAL: davepjr71
Me too stupud for all of you guyz on hear.
Me too stupud for all of you guyz on hear.
You said people have lost the real meaning of hunting. What exactly do you mean by that?
To me it reads that if you use a high poundage bow you've lost the meaning of hunting.
And comparing a high poundage bow to 300 mag is rediculous.
#134
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 2,188
Likes: 0
From: Balt, MD (orig: J-town,PA) The bowels of Hell!!!
You're only a year older than me grandpa!!!!
I've read every post. What i see makes me laugh. it's everyone's choice what they use. And, if you haven't figured out that Fran is busting your chops you need to relax and chill out a little.[8D]
When I started shooting in the late 70's pretty much every longbow shooterI knew had a bow higher tha 60#'s. They realized even what the Native Americans realized that the more effective the equipment the better off you are.
However, it seems today we have a reverse macho attitude that saysI can kill with a light weapon so thereforeI am superior to you andI know better.
I know that you can kill something with a tree branch with a string tied to it rated at 25 lbs if you wanted to.
I've read every post. What i see makes me laugh. it's everyone's choice what they use. And, if you haven't figured out that Fran is busting your chops you need to relax and chill out a little.[8D]
When I started shooting in the late 70's pretty much every longbow shooterI knew had a bow higher tha 60#'s. They realized even what the Native Americans realized that the more effective the equipment the better off you are.
However, it seems today we have a reverse macho attitude that saysI can kill with a light weapon so thereforeI am superior to you andI know better.
I know that you can kill something with a tree branch with a string tied to it rated at 25 lbs if you wanted to.
#135
Giant Nontypical
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 6,679
Likes: 0
From: Heaven is my home, temporarily residing in WNY :)
ORIGINAL: davepjr71
You're only a year older than me grandpa!!!!
I've read every post. What i see makes me laugh. it's everyone's choice what they use. And, if you haven't figured out that Fran is busting your chops you need to relax and chill out a little.[8D]
You're only a year older than me grandpa!!!!
I've read every post. What i see makes me laugh. it's everyone's choice what they use. And, if you haven't figured out that Fran is busting your chops you need to relax and chill out a little.[8D]
When I started shooting in the late 70's pretty much every longbow shooterI knew had a bow higher tha 60#'s. They realized even what the Native Americans realized that the more effective the equipment the better off you are.
However, it seems today we have a reverse macho attitude that saysI can kill with a light weapon so thereforeI am superior to you andI know better.
#136
No offense to anyone here, but saying that the Native Americans used their primitive weapons to take all the game in North America in defense of using a lighter poundage is just dumb.
It also took them a hunting party and about 30 of those pointy sticks with stones on the end to kill their prey. There was a video posteda while back of African tribes flinging spears into elephants as their means of hunting.
Just because it CAN be done doesn't mean it SHOULD be done.
It also took them a hunting party and about 30 of those pointy sticks with stones on the end to kill their prey. There was a video posteda while back of African tribes flinging spears into elephants as their means of hunting.
Just because it CAN be done doesn't mean it SHOULD be done.
#137
Giant Nontypical
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 6,679
Likes: 0
From: Heaven is my home, temporarily residing in WNY :)
ORIGINAL: HuntingBry
No offense to anyone here, but saying that the Native Americans used their primitive weapons to take all the game in North America in defense of using a lighter poundage is just dumb.
It also took them a hunting party and about 30 of those pointy sticks with stones on the end to kill their prey. There was a video posteda while back of African tribes flinging spears into elephants as their means of hunting.
Just because it CAN be done doesn't mean it SHOULD be done.
No offense to anyone here, but saying that the Native Americans used their primitive weapons to take all the game in North America in defense of using a lighter poundage is just dumb.
It also took them a hunting party and about 30 of those pointy sticks with stones on the end to kill their prey. There was a video posteda while back of African tribes flinging spears into elephants as their means of hunting.
Just because it CAN be done doesn't mean it SHOULD be done.
#138
Nontypical Buck
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 2,188
Likes: 0
From: Balt, MD (orig: J-town,PA) The bowels of Hell!!!
ORIGINAL: HuntingBry
No offense to anyone here, but saying that the Native Americans used their primitive weapons to take all the game in North America in defense of using a lighter poundage is just dumb.
It also took them a hunting party and about 30 of those pointy sticks with stones on the end to kill their prey. There was a video posteda while back of African tribes flinging spears into elephants as their means of hunting.
Just because it CAN be done doesn't mean it SHOULD be done.
No offense to anyone here, but saying that the Native Americans used their primitive weapons to take all the game in North America in defense of using a lighter poundage is just dumb.
It also took them a hunting party and about 30 of those pointy sticks with stones on the end to kill their prey. There was a video posteda while back of African tribes flinging spears into elephants as their means of hunting.
Just because it CAN be done doesn't mean it SHOULD be done.
#139
we need quick and germ back on here to lighten this thread back up again, I was all excited to read this thread this morning expecting a good laugh and I read all this arguing, man what a let down
#140
Alright here is the last word
Having a limit on KE is the way to go, example
Guy shooting a 50# Bowtech Guardian with a heavy arrow is going to have more KE than a guy shooting a PSE Nova with soft round wheels at 60# pounds with a lighter arrow.
Using WonderBoy(Quick) logic he would take the 60# bow because it is more manly[:'(]
I will use smart man logic(Huntinson) and shoot the bowtech, it is just that simple
As Motown would say Gospel

Having a limit on KE is the way to go, example
Guy shooting a 50# Bowtech Guardian with a heavy arrow is going to have more KE than a guy shooting a PSE Nova with soft round wheels at 60# pounds with a lighter arrow.
Using WonderBoy(Quick) logic he would take the 60# bow because it is more manly[:'(]
I will use smart man logic(Huntinson) and shoot the bowtech, it is just that simple

As Motown would say Gospel


