Which would you use and why? These are the only two heads in the poll because they are the only ones I own. I know either will kill a bird. Which will do it more effectively? Don't bother recommending other heads. I won't be buying any new ones. I will be shooting them through mesh in a pop-up. Thank you for your input, Greg

Bottom line it takes less force for a COC broadhead to enter into any game body.

I vote for COC.

Although I find it very interesting you shoot two different grain broadheads.

I use the 125gr Magnus out of my recurve. They shoot well out of my compound as well as I found out this afternoon. I normally use the Muzzy with the compound.

Of the 2 I would use the muzzy. Without buying different broadheads, I would at least consider adders to put behind them. It is about 3.00 or so for a package of 6. They won't shoot bad either......... With either of those by themselves, I would stay away from body shots and shoot for the base of the neck or head.

Which ever of the 2 that sports the biggest cutting diameter.....For turkeys, the bigger the hole the better.

How will they shoot through mesh with a back-up? I guess I can find out tomorrow. I'll give it a try and let ya'll know.

I'm not sure....But I don't think those adders will fly well at all through mesh..

Yeah, I have my concerns as well. I will take a shot at about 10 yds and see if it warrants continuing out to 20 yds or just giving up on the adders.

Unless you just don't have any choice because of the way the blind is built, forget the net....turkeys don't give a hoot anyway..

Turkeys gobble, cluck, and purr ...... owls give a hoot

I agree with Mobo .... ixnay the etnay