RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

id go with #1...all 3 seem to be trophys

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

I would shoot all three given the right oppurtunity. But if I had a choice, no contest No. 1.

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

I like the double throat patch on the 3rd buck

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

Number 1 is the only 1.

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

The first one gets my arrow!

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

#1 for sure
#2 I can't see real well.
#3 probably. He'd be game time decision

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

I like pic 2
easy shot what is that 10 feet!
If you can't kill from ten feet well what"ev
They"re all shooters depends on the Hunter and the tags left!!

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

The first one that came into Bow range. I did vote for #1 though!

Hatchet Jack

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

Nope, not close.....that's GregH's photo he snapped and passed on this deer because it was not 4.5 or up, Right Greg?

As for me, assuming your strictly talking comparison of animals and not shot position then number 1 was my pick.

RE: Which buck would you shoot?
 

Rob, Greg pm'd me a pic of this buck earlier this year and, I believe,said he couldn't get a shot at it. If I'm wrong, then GregH is crazy! [8D]

If I were judging the age of that particular buck, I would definately say he's at least 4.5 yrs old and is a STUD of an 8pt.