Which buck would you shoot?
Pic:1

pic:2

pic:3

the big 8pt in the 1st pic--he's giving the best shot

No contest No.1 is the best buck by far. If all 3 were in range and presented me with the same shot I would shoot #1, he is a monster.

If you are talking about the shot pictured. I don't think there is a good bow shot in any of those pics. No.1 is too far and the other 2 are bad shot angles.

I like 1 but i like 3 alittle more. I can see how wide it is, for all we know pic 1 could have a close rack and i dont like that.

wheres the all of the above?

if I could be that picky, I like the double patch

All of them are shooters but #1 is by far my first choice.

You can tell he's very tall symmetrical rack and he's got a huge body.

I'd shoot #1 for sure. He's for sure a 4-1/2 year old, maybe 5-1/2.

Not sure if I would shoot #2. I can't get a good look at him.

I wouldn't shoot #3. Give him onemore year for better tine length and thickness.