|
Which buck would you shoot?
Which buck would you shoot?
Pic:1  |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
pic:2
 |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
pic:3
 |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
the big 8pt in the 1st pic--he's giving the best shot
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
No contest No.1 is the best buck by far. If all 3 were in range and presented me with the same shot I would shoot #1, he is a monster.
If you are talking about the shot pictured. I don't think there is a good bow shot in any of those pics. No.1 is too far and the other 2 are bad shot angles. |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
I like 1 but i like 3 alittle more. I can see how wide it is, for all we know pic 1 could have a close rack and i dont like that.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
wheres the all of the above?
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
if I could be that picky, I like the double patch
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
All of them are shooters but #1 is by far my first choice.
You can tell he's very tall symmetrical rack and he's got a huge body. |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
I'd shoot #1 for sure. He's for sure a 4-1/2 year old, maybe 5-1/2.
Not sure if I would shoot #2. I can't get a good look at him. I wouldn't shoot #3. Give him onemore year for better tine length and thickness. |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
1 if I'm trying to manage my land. The other 2 aren't bad but there a little younger.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
I voted for #1 since I already did try to kill him once this year! Dang it! I missed![:o] BTW, he's about 20" wide.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
#1. It looks to have the most mass.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
LOVE the double throat patch but #1 for me.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
#1 for me also, great shot being offered too...
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
1 and2 (we can shoot two a day in VA) :D.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
i would shoot pic number 1 but the double trought patch is cool.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
#1 for sure because he is only one i can tell is mature, 2 you cant tell and 3 needs another year,but 1 would have to get closer because he is out of bow range and i dont gun hunt!!! Walt
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
I voted for buck #1, but there all nice bucks. I would take which ever one presented me with the best shot.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
# 1 would be getting shot at, look at the length of those G2's!
 |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
id go with #1...all 3 seem to be trophys
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
I would shoot all three given the right oppurtunity. But if I had a choice, no contest No. 1.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
I like the double throat patch on the 3rd buck
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
Number 1 is the only 1.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
The first one gets my arrow!
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
#1 for sure
#2 I can't see real well. #3 probably. He'd be game time decision |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
I like pic 2
easy shot what is that 10 feet! If you can't kill from ten feet well what"ev They"re all shooters depends on the Hunter and the tags left!! |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
The first one that came into Bow range. I did vote for #1 though!
Hatchet Jack |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
ORIGINAL: Doubled 150 I'd shoot #1 for sure. He's for sure a 4-1/2 year old, maybe 5-1/2. As for me, assuming your strictly talking comparison of animals and not shot position then number 1 was my pick. |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
ORIGINAL: Rob/PA Bowyer ORIGINAL: Doubled 150 I'd shoot #1 for sure. He's for sure a 4-1/2 year old, maybe 5-1/2. As for me, assuming your strictly talking comparison of animals and not shot position then number 1 was my pick. If I were judging the age of that particular buck, I would definately say he's at least 4.5 yrs old and is a STUD of an 8pt. |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
Well we know he is crazy[8D] because I could be mistaken, I was once, that he did pass it looking for his 10.....at least once anyway...[&:]
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
pic # 1
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
Actually Greg shot at it and missed it. I would like a stab at it also. Ofcourse the outcome would be different.:D
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
Motown, unfortunately is right, I missed the one in the pic. I tried to voice grunt him to a stop when I really didn't need to, he busted me and bolted as I took the shot.[&o]Dang it! I also had a bigger one than that (9 pt, 160s), come in behind me at 14 yards...no shot![:@]I'm still trying.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
ORIGINAL: GregH Motown, unfortunately is right, I missed the one in the pic. I tried to voice grunt him to a stop when I really didn't need to, he busted me and bolted as I took the shot.[&o]Dang it! I also had a bigger one than that (9 pt, 160s), come in behind me at 14 yards...no shot![:@]I'm still trying. |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
# 1 all the way.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
#1
If that buck was nice enough for Greg H to take a shot, then it is definitely shooter in anyones book. |
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
# 1 for me. I took the second picture so I know he is bigger than #3. They need at least one more year for me to shoot.
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
Any of the 3 if the gave me a good shot. As they stand now though it would be #1
|
RE: Which buck would you shoot?
Those all are very big bucks but 1would die.But pic 3, would be the best mount.
|
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:18 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.