I'm thinking he's 4 1/2.. But he could be 3 1/2. But his body looks older. Any takers?

yep, he'd be on my wall ifI got him!

big body, proly 3.5 or 4.5, i personally would let it fly

Every hunter is different. For some he is and for others he is not. It also depends on where you are hunting. If I'm in Ill., Iowa, or maybe Canada I would probably say no. I hunt in La., so I wouldn't hesitate. I would take him and be damn proud of it. Oh what the hell, I'd probably shoot him regardless of where I was. Yes, he is a shooter.

That much meat would be real hard to pass up , I'd blast him .

Thats a nice mature buck. Those g2's look to be 10 - 12 inches long. I would have to shoot.

I'd shoot him.

not even a question!!! the only thing I would have to think about is staying calm!

Well, if I had to guess, judging by antler mass and gut sag, I'd say he's a 4 1/2 year old.

The real question is...Is he a shooter to you? In my book, that arrow would be long gone. He's a nice one and i'd be willing to bet his rack is a little bigger than his body size depicts. Looks like a Canadian buck.

i'd say he's 4 1/2, anda shooter for surein my book, i would not even hesitate.