I think you need a pic with out the tree in the way to see whats going on . Nice buck anyway

Because it is his choice, and some of us just do not fling arrows at whatever walks by.

Again his choice, he wants to shoot bigger bucks, if this deer has adnormal genes he wants him out of the pool. His land, His choice

I didn't ask you.

Free country

Yup, picture quality is too poor to really be definite about anything with this deer. I don't care if it's broke off. You're looking at a mature buck who would be a nice one to take. I'm shooting. With this picture and the shadows I think you can't see all that's there. For example, you can't really see his right hind leg either. Is it gone? Probably not, but you can't see it. I think you'll find this deer has all the horns you want or need him to have to set your heart a flutter. I'd like to make his flutter with a Thunderhead.

Then why are you trying to speak for someone else?..........I never said you were not entitled to post.........just that I have no interest in your opinion. If I did, I would have asked you instead of the thread author.

Pretty simple concept.

I am not, simply said his choice on what he wants to do. Gave some examples, he will decide what he wants.

Notice the his land, his choice.

I think DaveMill is correct to hard to tell until we see a better picture.
It is the land owners choice, now there is a simple concept!

Please stay on topic

No..........you said......." Because it is his choice, and some of us just do not fling arrows at whatever walks by."........clearly including your 2 cents.


Did I say it wasn't?



That would be much easier if some people would stop speaking for others and answering questions not directed at them

Thank you Atlas I will change my post.

He can do whatever he wants it is his choice!!

Maybe he does not fling arrows at the everything, and he might want be trying to improve his deer herd. He will have to make the choice himself.

I support what ever he does

HE IS STILL A GOOD BUCK! I WOULD TAKE HIM!