RE: Can't eat antlers
 

LMAO

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

RyanPdadeerslayer - I've been hunting in PA long enough to know that there aren't too many guys who really "pass up eight points on a daily basis." When you meet a guy that does, you'll know he's telling the truth, b/c he'll have some beasts hanging in his living room. Furthermore, I've never even seen a 38 point buck. Soooo.....

Your neighbor might wanna check into a rehab clinic, or you could stage an intervention. One or the other.

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

Once again it goes back to why do you hunt and I want some of that stuff your neighbors on.

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

He always tells me his stories with a straight face! I also don't think he is telling the truth either.

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

Trust me This guy does have 3 monsters that look unreal mounted on his wall.

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

You'd take a doe OVER a big buck everytime? C'mon now.......

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

Turtle,

Does are more tender. So yes, everytime. I've only been presented with the option once and I took the doe. I usually don't let them walk for very long. Seconds maybe.

I don't keep wall mounts. I shot an eight pointer this year in Tennessee for muzzle loader. I kept the rack for a couple of days and then I threw it away. Now it wasn't anything to jump up and down about but it was still an eight pointer.

Tom

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

Hey Statjunk,
If you're going to throw those racks away why don't you mail them to me? I could use a new set of rattling horns!

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

Personally I have killed enough deer in my lifetime, that it is not just about killing something anymore. I dont consider myself a Trophy hunter only, but where I live you can only archery hunt for deer, and allowed only one buck. So yes until the last week of season I pass on alot of decent bucks. Then if I have had no luck, i get meat for the freezer.

I put to much work in scouting, hanging stands, and staying up at night all excited planning the next days hunt to just shoot the first average buck that walks by.

To each his own.

RE: Can't eat antlers
 

I've passed plenty of small or immature 8 points, but I would never pass on a 38 point buck . . . and neither would any other serious hunter. He never had any kind of chance at a 38 point or he would have shot.