Here is a buck I got a (bad)pic of during the rut last November.
How wide do you beleive this buck is?I have heardso many differing opinions, I thought post it on here to see what you guys would guess!

I have another pic of a buck I think may be the same one I'll post below, but once again you can judge that for yourself!

This buck looks 200+ lbs, and I THINK it may be the same buck???

In the last post I couldnt post picture? Here it is..same buck?

15, 16 inches let him grow. Do not shoot!

Doesn't look like the same buck to me. Neck bigger on second buck. Second may be a shooter, can't tell from the side. First buck is maybe 14-15" and doesn't look like a shooter.

Deer always look bigger from behind, and the first buck doesn't look that big.

I would have a hard time saying that both are the same buck as it is difficult to determine from the pictures in question. There should be no doubt that they look somewhat similar but I cannot say for sure. Rack width would be about 16-17 inches if I had to take a guess.

I can't say for sure if it's the same deer. The 1st looks to be in velvet,the 2nd is close to book. Nice pics, thanks for posting them.