Reason for regulations
07-10-2012 | 12:15 PM
#1
Guest
Posts: n/a
Reason for regulations
I'm sure there are good reasons for most of the regulations that exist in regards to hunting, but some of them are still hard for me to understand.
For example where I live you must use a 45 cal muzzleloader or larger.
I cannot use a .410 White for muzzy season. It's to small of a caliber according to the regs.
below in the picture the bullet on the right is a 410 gr for the .410 White . It is not legal for muzzy season
The bullet on the left is a 45 cal. It is legal
Yet during rifle season the regulations say that any shoulder held firearm producing 1000 ft pounds at the muzzle is legal for deer.
1500 ft pounds at the muzzle for Elk.
with only 90 gr of pyrodex or 777 I can meet the requirements so that I could hunt deer or elk with my 410 white during rifle season
but I cant use it for muzzy season
017 by 1874sharpsshooter, on Flickr
Oh well I dont make the rules I just follow them.
For example where I live you must use a 45 cal muzzleloader or larger.
I cannot use a .410 White for muzzy season. It's to small of a caliber according to the regs.
below in the picture the bullet on the right is a 410 gr for the .410 White . It is not legal for muzzy season
The bullet on the left is a 45 cal. It is legal
Yet during rifle season the regulations say that any shoulder held firearm producing 1000 ft pounds at the muzzle is legal for deer.
1500 ft pounds at the muzzle for Elk.
with only 90 gr of pyrodex or 777 I can meet the requirements so that I could hunt deer or elk with my 410 white during rifle season
but I cant use it for muzzy season
017 by 1874sharpsshooter, on Flickr
Oh well I dont make the rules I just follow them.
07-10-2012 | 12:27 PM
#2
Dominant Buck
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 21,193
Likes: 0
From: Wisconsin
They do that more so for the person that might have say a .40 caliber GMB and wants to shoot a .390 caliber roundball. Some of the small roundball barrels do not do well with large powder loads. So they lack in knock down power. And while I think a roundball even that small could kill deer at close range, it just is done because of the idiots that would be trying to knock one down at 100 or 150 yards. That is how it was explained to me by a warden when I asked the same question.
Now that .410 White you have is a game killer. That conical bullet would plant near any critter. But one reason they never interested me is it is basically a range rifle. Fun to shoot. Probably deadly accurate. But not legal for muzzle loader season. The same reason I did not purchase an Electra when they were on sale. In Wisconsin they are not legal in muzzleloader season. But they are in our modern rifle season. So it would be a range rifle toy.
Now that .410 White you have is a game killer. That conical bullet would plant near any critter. But one reason they never interested me is it is basically a range rifle. Fun to shoot. Probably deadly accurate. But not legal for muzzle loader season. The same reason I did not purchase an Electra when they were on sale. In Wisconsin they are not legal in muzzleloader season. But they are in our modern rifle season. So it would be a range rifle toy.
07-10-2012 | 12:32 PM
#3
Guest
Posts: n/a
They do that more so for the person that might have say a .40 caliber GMB and wants to shoot a .390 caliber roundball. Some of the small roundball barrels do not do well with large powder loads. So they lack in knock down power. And while I think a roundball even that small could kill deer at close range, it just is done because of the idiots that would be trying to knock one down at 100 or 150 yards. That is how it was explained to me by a warden when I asked the same question.
Now that .410 White you have is a game killer. That conical bullet would plant near any critter. But one reason they never interested me is it is basically a range rifle. Fun to shoot. Probably deadly accurate. But not legal for muzzle loader season. The same reason I did not purchase an Electra when they were on sale. In Wisconsin they are not legal in muzzleloader season. But they are in our modern rifle season. So it would be a range rifle toy.
Now that .410 White you have is a game killer. That conical bullet would plant near any critter. But one reason they never interested me is it is basically a range rifle. Fun to shoot. Probably deadly accurate. But not legal for muzzle loader season. The same reason I did not purchase an Electra when they were on sale. In Wisconsin they are not legal in muzzleloader season. But they are in our modern rifle season. So it would be a range rifle toy.
I only hunt with a muzzy even during rifle season so i might as well give it a chance
