BobCo19-65 wrote:
Like I said, if you feel superior, why not take it up with the man himself. I'd love to see the conversation and it is very possible to do.
Where do you get the idea that I feel superior. You must figure that if someone disagrees with something then they feel superior? I know I may sound a bit know it all "ish" and I appolgize for that but I don't appolize for being educated and knowlegeable in physcis and mechanics. I enjoy discussing archery mechanics and I thought the "technical" forum under "Bowhunting" might be a good place to indulge myself. Maybe I was wrong. It seems that too many here view personal attack as a valid form of technical discussion. Anyway, I would enjoy a conversation with Dr. Ashby. You would proabably be disappointed though. I disagree with him on only a minor point. Turns out that it was you who was arguing that KE has nothing to do with penetration. In his paper Ashby doesn't say that at all, but rather says it plays a very minor role when compared to the broadhead design.