Noel Feather's rattlin' antlers. Yes sir! I rattled in my first buck the first time I tried them. Was on a "HOT" rub line in So. Illinois & that big 8 pointer came in & rubbed a small tree till it fell down. Had him @ 25 yards, but never gave me a bow shot. I was gutted. But they convinced me in a hurry. If you don't have a pair of sheds, these will do just fine. Just because you tried them once w/ no success, does not mean they are garbage. I mean, if you don't pay more than $15-$25 for them, you aren't really out much if you decide a "K-Meer Deer" call works better. Just my $.02

Quakklz