RE: Which has more recoil, the Short Mag or the non Short Mag
I say the win mag does. The recoil formula we are used to seeing takes into account the amount of powder. I do find it to be right. The win mag uses slower powder and the recoil is different, maybe not more or less. But you usually use more of it. I mean so much of it has to do with the shape of the stock, and inside barrel dimenions, etc.