A couple years ago I shot a buck that was with a group of about 10 deer. The group had two other bucks and a piebald doe. The next day I went to the same stand and right around the same time the same group came right up the same path and I took one of the other two bucks! So you never know. Deer are creatures of habit and they seem to stick to those habits most of the time. It's worth a shot if you ask me...Good Luck!