RE: which would be more of a trophy.
When I was younger I would take any legal animal. In my 20"s I began to seek out "trophy class" animals. Today in my mid thirties, I seem to be more intrested in a quality hunting expierence. For example, I intend to take my wifes 30.30 open sight Winchester mule deer hunting this year. I am not concerned so much with the size of the buck, just that I would like to take it with a western classic rifle, no gizmos or scopes.