I have the Marlin 17V, paid around $180 for it about one year ago. My opinion I felt the Marlin was a little higher quality, better fit and finish than the Savage. I lightened the trigger and that is all, this rifle is capiable of sub MOA accuracy, on the same note my shooting buddy bought the Savage and it shoots just as well. I don't think you can go wrong with either, it is a matter of what feels better to you. Enjoy, the 17's are addicting!