I would buy that 30-30 deffinately, under 200 dollars is a super deal. In the real world and when it comes to killing a deer there really is no difference in killing performance between a 30-30 and 35 rem. Based on the fact that 30-30 is more popular and a easier to find caliber I would have to say I would take the 30-30 over a 35 remington any day.