RE: Something not right with draw length.
Well your dealer does have a point, your not supposed to be able to buy new mathews over the internet. And one of the reasons is because of what just happened to you. The other is to insure that the dealer can sell the bows they order. That way you can't go there and shoot one, then go home and order one for hundred dollars less on the net. That however does not stop someone from buying it, then selling it right a way. Then it isn't new anymore. It's used even if it has never been shot. And the waranty is not transferable when you sell a mathews, it's for the original owner only I believe. You should have said you were getting one "like new" from someone on the internet. Or just said you were buying it from some guy knew or something. Sometimes mathews will still warranty the bow any way though.
Paul