I used both, including the Trophy taker pretty hard. Here is my two cents:

The Trophy is accurate, very accurate. But, IMO too noisy and I don't like fussing with the moleskin on the prongs. I am also not a big fan of a string hook-up to the cable. Always made me nervous.

The Trophy Ridge is a nice rest. Quiet, durable and seems the accuracy is very good as well. But its a mammoth of a rest in size and weight and I dont care for the string hook up again.

One thing I noticed about both is the arrow containment stinks on both. The Trophy Taker does not contain the arrow well from the factory. Either did the Trophy Ridge.

Just my two cents.