Bass Pro pales in comparison. I have been to the Mich. and PA Cabelas (PA - 4 times) and was just at the new BPS in NY. There is no doubt that Cabelas is 10x better. More stuff by far. The BPS is nice to have in your town and the fishing selection is good (no more than Cabelas though), but I would easily drive the tree hours to Cabelas over the 1.5 hour to BPS. For example the BPS has no truck accessories and little ATV stuff. Hunting supplies are adequate, but archery selection is a bit small. I would still go to BPS when i was in the area, but wouldn't make a special trip. Just my view.