HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - ELK GUN 270 ?
View Single Post
Old 04-27-2004 | 11:14 PM
  #27  
CalNewbie
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 352
Likes: 0
From: Raleigh NC USA
Default RE: ELK GUN 270 ?

A few questions - is the 270 what you have and is it something you can shoot well?
You mentioned the 7MM. A 7mm mag would be better, a 30-06 or a 300 mag better still, and a 338 plenty, but if you have the 270, shoot it well, and would prefer not to make a rifle purchase the 270 will work.

Illinois is a shotgun only state isn't it? If so, I can understand not wanting to make a rifle purchase if you don't have to.

A 270 with a proper load will kill elk. I think you should re-consider your choice of ammo though. A better choice would be a 150 grain Nosler Partition. Federal Cartridge makes them. A ballistic-tip might come apart and fail to adequately penetrate on an elk.

There's an good article in the latest issue of Guns & Ammo asking if we're overgunned? The author, Craig Boddington, makes a case for a "yes" answer. In his article Mr. Boddington makes the point that he likes the 338 for elk, but that a 270 will work also. He ranks caliber below shot placement and bullet selection. It boils down to a good bullet that you can confidently place on target.

You mentioned that you primarily bow hunt, so you're certain to understand shot placement. An elk hunt video showed a guided hunt with a 270 wby mag. The elk was able to soak up quite a bit of punishment - 4 shots to bring it down. You were able to see the bullet tracks in the mist/air and the first went into the belly, the second and third were similarly poorly placed, and only the fourth went into the heart/lung area, dropping him. Luckily for the hunter the elk stood there and took it. It it had bolted after the first shot things wouldn't have turned out so well.
CalNewbie is offline  
Reply