I think the bodoodle and whisker bisquit are good rests as is the GKF whisper disk and APA ultimate when it comes to arrow contaniment. But personally i would try the RIPCORD arrow rest before I used the afore mentioned style of rest. It is capable of complete arrow containment and is easier on your vanes or feathers than even the best standard containment rest. Just my opionon the others are good rests and will do the job, but I think this one does it all.