They are both great broadheads. I really liked the Montecs and I thought they shot really well but they were'nt sharp enough for me. Also, I don't want to have to re-sharpen everytime I kill something or miss something. I prefer something with a replaceable blade. That way I can have razorsharp broadheads everytime and I have a bountiful supply of practice blades without dulling my hunting blades. When I do shoot one through a deer in a about 15 seconds I can take an old tooth brush to them and slap new blades in them and I have a brand new head. Either one of those heads will work great. For me it's a matter of cost and conveinience.