I was on a $1250 lease in south Texas that allowed me to take only one buck. Fired what I knew was a fatal shot at a nice 10 pointer, but took it right at dark just before a blue norther brought a big rainstorm. Didn't find him that night or the next day. As far as I was concerned, my tag was filled. Even though the lease allowed me to take another buck, I just couldn't bring myself to keep hunting. Found the rack several weeks later. I have it nailed to the barn in an out of the way place, but all it reminds me of is my failure as a hunter. I get no pleasure from the nice rack.
Every experienced hunter has had a similiar story TXhunter so don't feel bad....
I believe that such a policy would reduce the chances of people taking low percentage shots for fear of wounding an animal
People that aren't familiar with their firearms and capabilities as well as their own physical/mental capabilities shouldn't be booking expensive hunts where Murphy's law is sometimes the only law. Put people in this situation and your asking for failure because of their expectations after shelling out a small fortune for a hunt.