Stealthycat,

You said it all. I have shot all kinds of broad heads, and I will say arrow placement is everything. I am a teacher of Bow hunters Ed. and we try to teach our new archers not to take shots that far. For your first deer I personally believe that you shot to far. Take the blame on your self if you can admit to your self and others that it was your fault then you will become a better hunter.

Groundhunter,

I wish you the best of luck with up coming hunts, don't give up we have all been in your shoes.