I was skeptical of Rompola's buck also, but I read an article about the Rompola update (in NAH in beleive) about the columnist who saw the Rompola video the next day (where he walks up to it...videoing the whole thing), and saw the kill scene. He claims there is nothing fishy at all...just the "PROS" who KILL DEER IN FENCES, on game farms claiming its a fake....go figure. He also signed a contract while joining a club(anti P&Y????) in Michigan where he can NEVER enter a buck in B&C or P&Y as long as he lives (something to that sort...I was confused on this, but the article showed his sig. and the "contract" from the early 90s or late 80s...something I never knew). Another note, he has an amazing number of bucks that EASILY make either BC or PY, his wall is like nothing I have seen...but never entered 1 of them in the record books, only entered a few when he was younger b4 the "contract." The author of the article also says he saw live footage of the deer...something I never knew b4 either. I am a true beleiver!