So I didn't read through the WHOLE thread but I had this happen twice.

1. where the guy shooting the kill shot had tagged out already ( I claimed it and gave him a full hindquarter). I made a shot and destroyed the liver with an '06. He was killed within 65 yards of the initial shot , a 4 by 5 with a wide rack.

2. I shot a small forkhorn buck (running) high (probably a non kill, though it did hit the spine), the last day of the season, and I claimed it; as the other guy had also tagged out. I provided 2 good packs of steaks to him.

SMALL TOWN, everyone knows everyone. What's the response now?

YES, I've learned to shoot much more accurate since those days.

You may ask what were they doing in the woods? They were "Coyote hunting".

REM7600