Rockport is correct and so is C-tom. Had the action not been legal I would not have allowed it. Are you arguing for the sake of argument or what. You sure aren't arguing from the standpoint of of the law, just your opinion which is incorrect. Two men each shot the same deer at different times. They came together over the body of the deer and came to a decision as to whose deer it should be and that person tagged the deer making it legally his. It is that simple, don't over analyze a simple situation.