I have no idea which brands are better than the other, let alone, if any of them work at all. I do use laundry detergent & body wash (Cheapest brand from Wally World), but I have been busted a time or 2. The best way to cover your scent is to hunt the wind. Have multiple stands on your property(if able), then figure out which way the wind is blowing that day and decide which stand to hunt from there.