I bought a crossbow last season and shot the Toxic broad head out of it and couldn't get any really good accuracy out of them. Then I put on a 3 bladed Rage expandable and it hit like a field point. I also shot a buck with it, so expandables are my preference. As stated before, you owe it to the animal you hunt to make sure you know where that arrow hits with your broad head of choice on it. Oh, and the arrows I hunted with were aluminum but I will be getting carbon when I head on my next out of state hunt.