I would have to agree with both Muley and Flags. I would for sure get both tags if available. You never know if you will encounter both species and have them be a quality animal. But not having the tag in your pocket would be a sad day. 300+ bull elk is still trophy in my book any day. If I was on a hunt and killed a 300+ bull and a 24+ inch muley I would consider myself a blessed man. Especially in 5 to 9 day hunts.