I have not tried the Verifier but what size peep do you have on there?
Several things can cause this.
Have somebody watch your draw and make sure that peep is lining up perfect, your draw length could also be set to short and the peep is not coming back far enough or the peep could just be to small.
Now days they seem to want to set everything up like your an Olympic archer trying to hit clearly lit bulls eyes at 100 yards when what you really need is to be able to hit a volleyball at 30 yards at sunset.