You did ask for honest opinions.
I think it looks like a Koala bears face. I'm not laughing, I really think it does if you look at a koala bear picture and a deer picture. I have a tatoo and so does my wife and many friends. I have seen good ones and bad ones. Mottz has a sharp tatoo there and it looks really good. I would find an artist that can show you their work with copying a photograph of a person. I think you will then find a person that can give you what you really want. The tatoo idea and things going along with it are good but the deers face is really missing some features. Those features and details will set it apart from a tatoo that you look at going eh, hmm, yeah i like it from Now that is what i'm talking about! How awesome is this! Just my opinion.
Only thing that matters is what you think but that being said if you didn't care what people think of your tatoo when they see it then you wouldn't have asked our opinions.