I'm new to the forum and was browsing when I saw this thread. It is harder to age them this time of the year. Having said that, the deer's antler bases look as if they are at least 1 1/2 maybe twice the size of his eyes. He appears larger in the front than the rear, bigger in the girth, and long. I'm gonna put him at 4 to 4 1/2. He does appear to have those " post" looking front legs. I would love to see him in rut. Easier to age later in the year, closer to rut. My observation only. Wait and see.