I have or I should say had them both. the block will last longer its deeper on the layers are tighter. I bought a blackhole this spring and I would not recomend this target at all not for the price. Even if you shot just feildpoints it would not last you any longer than a 20-25 $ bag target. I was just using it for feild points then I took it out for one session of broadhead practice and now its pretty much toast. Broadheads will destroy any targer fast. I had my block for maybe a year and a half before it was totall toast. I had the pro model and shot broadheads through it but not on a regular basis just enough to know they were hitting with my feild points. I' d go with the block over the blackhole. But personally I' d like to find something that could take broadheads better.