Curious as to others opinions on this too. I know I use Pete Rickards indian buck lure from NY alot down here in NC and have good results.
Especially when I used it in the past in Oregon alond the coast. The Blacktail deer there are real territorial, so when I'd put a Whitetail deer scent trail down of the indian buck lure they'd follow it like I was reeling them in like a bass. Never had as excellent results with a scent like that.
If anybody is hunting blacktail deer try the Pete Rickards indian buck lure. You have my word that if it don't work on them blacktails I'll buy back any ya have left.
On whitetail it works alright but not like out there. Not sure if this is really relevant to the orginal post, nut my .02 cents.
good luck