By far go with the short barrel the mvp is a hard call and if you are really good you can make it scream but I cant. I have made a living with my short barrel and I am not a pro staffer. If you want a little more aggressive call get a daisy cutter. Those are two really good calls that will do anything you could want. I am not a fan of zinks duck calls but there goose calls are the best. Whatever you get practices practices practices.