Thats kinda crappy, but it happens and I believe if two hunters shoot the same deer, the one who makes the last fatal shot wins, I know it sucks but it's true, Sorry about what happend, If I see a nice buck walking passed my stand and he has a hole in him I would also shoot him, if when I found him and a nother hunter said he shot it first and had the arrow to prove it, I would probably let him have it, after all he shot it first. but that's just me. Big deer will make some people do crazy things.