sounds like ya mighta grazed him with the duk n turn move..bright red...and good blood trail...you have game cams? put one where ya shot him at..he'll be back sooner or later...i jus read a post (as have many other people had this same pic) where the deer is on cam and you can see the arrow bulgin on the shoulder, i am interested to see as well....if ya told me ya had a broadhead and 2 inches of shaft in a deer, i'd usually say there is a dead deer, but i am proved wrong with these post.