Facing the same dilemma now. I had the most forgiving, pleasant shooting, accurate bow I ever had. A bowtech commander. I went and got a guardian. Its ok. But not near as forgiving with a 30" draw, hense not as accurate, draw cycle sucks compared to the commander, and not as quiet.

Only reason I sold the commander and got the guardian was I was thinking I better unload the commander now. It was an 07 and they had no resale and price was shooting down by the day. The guardian does. Sure the guardian is 10fps faster, but at a horrible draw cycle.