At some level, we are talking apples and oranges here.

If you were talking elk or deer that someone can go hunting at that location every year or two, I would guard those locations VERY carefully and only share with close hunting buddys.

However, we are talking about a handful of tags given out. If I was not going to hunt them, and no one I know was going to hunt them, and this guy who is asking is not going to hunt them again anytime in the next decade (which he won't), I don't see the harm in sharing their location with him.

This is not the same as giving away a "honey hole".

Search yourself and you will find the answer, what we think doesn't count!