Both will do just fine for you. It really does come down to personal taste.
The 24" barrel on the BPS may or may not be easier to get a good pattern with. In all the testing that I have done the "overbored" barrels tend to be easier to pattern than "standard" sized barrels so you should not have a problem with either barrel getting a good pattern.
Personally, I would go with the BPS but again that is just personal preference.