Brian they are all capable of killing and shooting well! but in the test we have done for cost and simple good solid working gun the H&R was the hands down winner! it really shines past the normal ranges like 150 yds ! bes tthing you can do is get it zero it at 50yds about 2.5-2.75 inches high then re shoot it at 100yds! you should be on the money no trouble sligs must be zeroed at supersonic speeds! unlike rifles which are zeroed at 100yd shotguns must be zeroed at 50 ! and oh boy talk about wind! a 5-10 mile an hour wind can blow you off a target by 9 inches at that speed! it takes a lot of ammo down range to judge that ! but hey thats why we practice! let me know if i can be of help !