Hey Kelly...I thought you just gave up boots all together? [8D]Seemed to work pretty well for you this year....LOL

Edit: I might as well say that I have had about the same experience using either one. I haven't seen a noticeable difference with either. Been scented in both, and not scented in both. [&:]Biggest buck I ever had within bow range scented my track in the rubber boots....needless to say I didn't get a shot.