I've tried the Western Rivers Mighty Max, which was very uncomfortable to wear, too heavy, and the Petzl Tactikka XP, I couldn't get it to fit tight enough and it kept slipping and the battery life was short. Both lights worked OK, but for the money, IMO not worth it. The energizer 6 led head lamp is real light and comfortable to wear, battery life is great, last me all season and at a price of $14. JMO.