I have not had much luck with any type of call here in upstate NY. I have had buck come within visual sight while bow hunting and have tried grunt calls. Most times they dont even look and go about their way. I have had better response with the Can type calls. It has at least had the deer stop and look in the direction that the sound is coming from. However, I have some friends that hunt not that far from where I do and have alot of luck with them. I guess I havent had the right buck in the right state of mind come by me yet. I still carry both, especially when bow hunting because you never know!
MIKE