I had a good friend go 2 weeks ago and he was not happy at all. They make it sound like you can shoot a trophy, a management trophy, a cull buck and does. When he got there the first thing they said was no does. No big deal he can still shoot the bucks. Well he pays for the guide to make sure he shoots a management trophy or a cull that will not go against his trophy buck. Well a 3 year old 8 pt walks out and the guide tells him to shoot it, so he does. The deer scores 106 inches but has a 16 inch spread, so this makes it his trophy buck, and they tell him this is a trophy, and since he shot a trophy he can not shoot another trophy buck. So now he can not shoot a manage ment trophy either. He did not geta shot at a cull so he did not shoot a cull either. i know it is ultimately up to the hunterto pull the trigger, and he should have told the guide he would not shoot, but he is new to hunting and paid for the guide for this reason.There were no big deer shot while he was there, 3 other small 8 pts were killed. They also say that you can re book for half price during the same season if you do not kill, but there are no openings so that wont happen, this happend to one of the hunters that was on the hunt with my friend. I know they have big deer on Giles Island, and i have always wanted to go. But after seeing what he paid for it and what he killed, i will not be making a trip there. May be this is just something that happened once, and is notthe norm. I am not trying to bash Giles Island, and my friend said it was a top notch place as far as the accomadations go, I just wanted to tell you what happened to him.