RE: have you ever seen this deer?
Seriously, you guys that don't live in PA shouldn't comment on the Amish in PA. They are miserable people when it comes to "hunting." The laws are loosened severely for them and they still don't follow the minimal guidelines that there are. They have no regard for property boundaries and no regard for other hunters or their safety. They will not think twice to shoot EVERY deer off of a given piece of property and they feel like if you give one permission to hunt you just gave the whole damn clan permission.
If you don't know what you speak of with these people then do not speak. I certainly will not comment on the Amish in WI, KY, OH, or anywhere else, but around here they are not well liked.