Do you know how to paper tune? I'd guess your rest is set too far in or out.

Did you get the same arrow shafts? Is the only difference the vanes? If not sure look to see if the number on the shaft is the same.

If so, are your cock feathers turned straight up when you place the arrow on the string? If not, put them on the string and turn the arrow so that it is. The nock should allow the arrow to turn around it. Or you can turn the nocks by hand either one.

Next get a cardboard box and cut a hole about a foot square or larger if you can in the bottom. Now tape a piece of newspaper over the hole Single Layer of paper. Tape it tight, no wrinkles. Now put this about 4 ft from your target and in line with it so that the arrow will go through and hit the target to stop it. Now, back up about 6-8ft from the box and shoot 2 or 3 arrows through the paper. See how the holes look.
You should see where the tip hit and where the fletch cut. It should be just one hole, but if you are getting a whip it will show up here. Let us know which way they are tearing. For instance a hole to the left and a tear with the fletch cuts above and to the right would be a high/right tear. Then note how far the tear is between the point and fletch end. 1" or 4" or whatever it is.

You can try moving the rest one way or another and repeating the steps to see if it helps. But remember only one direction at a time and only small amounts at first until you are more comfy doing this. Don't overshoot the mark.

HINT: Be sure the hole in your WB is lined up with the hole in your riser as far as up and down goes. If off, are you comfortable in moving it to realignit? Next...Hold it out at arms length with an arrow nocked and in the rest. Line the string up with the cams and the space between the limbs. Is your rest hole in line with all of this? Is the tip of your arrow sticking to one side or the other? If it is obviously out to one side, do you feel comfy in moving it to realign? If so then be sure your rest is all tight and screws secure when finished and that hole lines up both ways as described. Also be sure your rest biscuitis not leaning significantly forward or backward and the arrow is lying flat on the bristles...WITH THE COCK FEATHER UP. No fletch should be hitting the black bristles. NOW you are ready to paper tune as noted above. The thing with the WB is that you have to make all these adjustments one at a time and preferrably in the order I described. Always check to be sure moving it to align it one direction didn't change another.

If this is too much...I would try to find a smaller shop than Bass Pro to do it for you. They are not known for taking the time to do good tuning. Or maybe we can talk you through it.

When does your season start...I live in WV....Latest starting archery season in the US several years running. Our seasons and limits only serve to do one thing...make money.